Services

Why Do We Talk Clients Out of Buying Tchotchkes?

Why Do We Talk Clients Out of Buying Tchotchkes?

var(--variable-nOOk3AkhY)

We sell gifts for a living, and a surprising amount of our sales calls go to talking people out of them.

Every week, a client comes up with a creative item for their lumpy mail campaign. (Hourglasses come up a lot.)

So I always ask clients to picture opening a package and finding a novelty hourglass. Cute pun on the card. Now what do you do with it?

You already know. You look at it, you say "huh," and it goes in the junk drawer. Or the trash can.

That's a tchotchke. Here's why we try to steer people away from them, and what we recommend sending instead.

Where Does a Tchotchke Actually End Up?

The junk drawer, the trash, or home to the kids, to go in THEIR junk drawer.

The sender often only goes as far as thinking about the initial reaction and how it ties in with their marketing message. Many don't consider what happens to the item after that.

Nobody is upset to receive one, but it's just as forgettable as every other tchotchke lying around their office.

Why Would a Gifting Company Talk You Out of a Gift?

Because we'd rather see your campaign succeed than be "yes" men or women.

We want clients to keep working with us because the last campaign was successful.

There's also a common misread of how lumpy mail works:

  • Lumpy gets the package opened. A box beats a flat envelope every time, so that's true.

  • Useful gets it kept, and gets you remembered long after the box is opened.

We're not building campaigns for that first fleeting reaction. We're building them so people remember you.

Isn't a Clever Item Enough?

No. Clever gets a polite exhale through the nose. Funny or useful gets a reply. And isn't that the whole point?

Most gimmick items run on grandpa humor. You read the pun, you think "oh, that's clever," and you go back to your inbox.

Compare that to a campaign we ran for a med tech company selling to private medical offices. Their prospects were frustrated with their fax machines. So we mailed boxing gloves.

  • Real, full-size boxing gloves.

  • An instruction card showing them how to beat their fax machine.

  • A handwritten card on top with the recipient's name on it.

20 of the first 110 offices responded.

It worked because it's ridiculous, and because gloves are a real thing a person takes home. A follow-up is already scheduled for those who didn't respond. (We built this campaign around stress relief, so you can imagine the funny items to come.)

What Should You Send Instead?

Keep the message. Swap the object for something the person will actually use.

Your message

The tchotchke version

What we'd send

"Burned by your last agency?"

A novelty flame stress toy

A first aid kit with bandages and burn ointment

"Ready to break up with your vendor?"

A plastic broken heart

An 8-pack of tissues, enough for the entire office

"Your fax machine is making you miserable"

A fax-shaped stress ball

Real boxing gloves, with instructions

"Come find us at booth 52"

A logo pen or keychain

A travel kit of things people usually forget to pack

That last one is a favorite. For a client heading to a conference, we packed a nice unbranded toiletry bag with name-brand basics:

  • Deodorant, toothbrush, toothpaste, floss

  • Mouthwash, mints, tissues

  • Hand sanitizer wipes

The handwritten card said there was one more thing we couldn't fit in the bag, and to come claim it at the booth. (It was a portable charger.)

The booth got swamped. Attendees who registered late and missed the mailing asked how to get one. The client started at 100 kits and sent an additional 330 for the next conference.

Nobody has ever chased down a vendor for a logo pen.

How Do You Spot a Tchotchke Before You Order 500 of Them?

Run it through four questions. One "no" is a warning. Two and it's out.

  1. Would you keep it? Picture it on your own desk in a month.

  2. Can they use it this week? Coffee, tissues, a charger, a decent bag. Boring is fine. Boring gets used.

  3. Is it a brand they'd recognize and buy themselves? Name brands read as generous. Generic reads as leftover.

  4. Does it get a real reaction? A laugh, a "who sent this," a photo to a coworker. A quiet "cute" doesn't count.

What If Your Idea Is Only Half-Baked?

Send it anyway. Half-baked is our favorite kind, because we get to finish it with you.

Even if you have no idea what to send, come find us. We really only need to know:

  • Who you're trying to reach

  • What their pain point is, or what you can do for them

  • How you want them to respond

Part of working with GhostHandwriter is that we build custom campaigns that tackle your most challenging sales and marketing problems.

Ready to execute a campaign that no one else is doing?

want us to handle it?

Tell us the outcome. We’ll handle the rest.

Handwritten cards and lumpy mail, planned, written, packed, and shipped for you.

Book A Strategy Call
Book A Strategy Call

Get A Free Sample Pack